ESG in simplicity stands for Environmental, Social and ( corporate) Governance issues and the material impact these issues can have on company performance and share price. Consideration and analysis of these issues, offers an extra layer of risk management and an opportunity to exclude or reduce investment in a company, where its inclusion may effect the long term stability of the investment portfolio or pension fund.
The term ESG was first mentioned by Klaus Topfler, the Executive Director of the UN Environment Programme in the forward of the 2004 report, " The Materiality of Social, Environmental and Corporate Governance Issues to Equity Pricing"(https://www.unepfi.org/fileadmin/documents/amwg_materiality_equity_pricing_report_2004.pdf)
That states:
"Too many analysts and financial institutions tend to insufficiently acknowledge and appreciate environmental, social and corporate governance issues. The results of this project show that such a bias may expose investors and companies to unnecessary risk. Environmental, social and corporate governance thinking must therefore be fully integrated into our market, investment and board room considerations by those that wish to create the foundation for, and then realise, long-term shareholder value". Topfler 2004
Ten years on from this pivotal report, investors are more engaged with ESG issues and companies are being asked for their environmental, social and corporate governance performance. Supporting this has been a growing ESG reporting ecosystem, (https://widgets.weforum.org/esgecosystemmap/index.html#/)which includes amongst many initiatives, organisations that are, collating data, developing reporting frameworks, setting standards, providing voting and engagement services.
Whilst we wait for an international standardisation for ESG reporting, it is worth acknowledging the work of SASB. Formed in 2011 the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board is a non profit organisation that has helped to develop a set of standards for the disclosure of financially material information by companies to investors. SASB identified 26 broadly relevant issues u(https://sasb.org/standards/materiality-map/)nder five areas, environment, social capital, human capital, business model and innovation, leadership and governance.
The table below shows priority consideration for analysis under the E. S. and G heading and how these areas can effect long term shareholder value and thus the future value of your pension and investments.
Failing to take ESG issues seriously, or more to the point investors concern over ESG issues, can have disastrous results for even the largest of companies. We don't have too far to look back to remember Volkswagen where $42.5 billion was lost in two months when they were found to be cheating in how they measured diesel emissions. Meta, the owners of Facebook experienced a 40% drop in their share price, estimated to be a $400 billion drop in value in a space of two weeks. The company's leadership may well have opted for money and growth but this backfired when advertisers judged the company to be far less attractive after serious data breaches and shortcomings in data security were disclosed. As data and information on companies becomes more available, investors can ask tougher questions, all with an aim of maintaining long term shareholder value.
ESG investing is an investment-related activity that accounts for some type of ESG consideration. It is not a separate asset class, a single strategy or even a single type of action and importantly, the appropriate approach is not the same for all investors. ESG investing is primarily concerned with risk management and protecting investment returns, whilst there are some crossovers with ethical considerations for some investors, it is not the same as ethical screening.
At the moment ESG has risen in recognition and is used as a popular acronym and an umbrella term for Sustainable, Ethical, Socially Responsible and Impact Investing, where there are overlapping issues. As a consequence it can be confusing and care must be taken to understand the type of ESG analysis that is employed by an investment fund or within a portfolio and whether the ESG analysis, actually does what it says on the tin.
With this in mind, in November 2023 the financial regulator in the UK, the FCA published their policy report, "Sustainability Disclosure Requirements (SDR) and investment labels (https://www.fca.org.uk/publications/policy-statements/ps23-16-sustainability-disclosure-requirements-investment-labels) with the aim of making it easier for consumers to know how their money is being invested, to reduce greenwashing and unsubstantiated claims by pension funds and investment managers.
Hope this helps you understand the background to ESG analysis and there's some links below to explore further.
Do get in touch with your questions.
Further resources :
.